Date
Author
James Downer
Infrastructure
Field Notes: Undercollateralized DeFi Pilot in Colombia
How a Celo pilot testing undercollateralized credit for Venezuelan migrants in Colombia used social collateral to double incomes — and grew into Roda, reaching over 200 individuals.

Reading time
5 minutes
Share
How might we deploy credit which unleashes potential for 5B mobile phone users around the world?
When designing new financial systems for unbanked populations we must always begin with what financial primitives already exist. Credit, as experienced in the west, is a historical anomaly. Centralized credit bureaus who don’t know their clients are immensely useful for scaling credit, but they do not draw from the nuances of the daily life of the billions of people without access to credit.
Celo ran a pilot in the first half of 2020 during COVID lockdowns to test a set of hypotheses around undercollateralized credit for Venezuelan migrants residing in Colombia. The conclusions are that p2p systems, collateralized on social relationships, can decrease both the cost of capital and the cost of operations for lenders in emerging markets. Easily programmable money (crypto) plays an important role in structuring and rewarding these incentive structures and stands to rewrite credit systems across emerging economies and beyond.
Read on for details on how the pilot was run.
We met Jorge as the first lockdowns arrived in Colombia. He’s a lifelong entrepreneur and father. He immigrated to Colombia with hope of providing a better life for his family. He works as a bike messenger by day but dreams of owning his own business again.
Jorge hasn’t just rebuilt his own life in Bogotá, he has helped his community rebuild their lives. The lack of formal solutions prompted Jorge to start a savings circle with a group of fellow immigrants. Together they establish financial goals, access money they need, and support each other on the paths towards achieving their goals. In addition to this saving group, Jorge was also making small personal loans to other migrants to help them establish themselves. The existence of this savings group and the mutual trust among the members allowed Celo to reach a high-risk migrant population who already had a shared social fabric.
The Pilot
As families around the world were under shelter-in-place orders, people turned to delivery services. The delivery service market is expected to grow from $540 billion in 2019 to $824 billion by 2023. Demand for couriers is booming. Immigrants like Jorge help to fill this demand. Most of the couriers in Colombia use a manual pedal bicycle, but a motorized bicycle is a game changer.
As part of our pilot, each participant received a $500 loan to purchase a beach cruiser that was retrofitted with a 66cc, two-stroke motor. This bike not only extended their range and speed but doubled their income.
Lending on Celo has several advantages over traditional financial institutions. It provides:
Access to anyone with a mobile phone
Better terms than existing solutions
Increased transparency
The ability to program loans and incentives
A blueprint for a client-custodial credit score
We looked at the best of these informal networks and used it as a basis to assess credit worthiness and likelihood of repayment. In the case of Jorge, he was able to use his social collateral to vouch for others to obtain a loan.

A small loan can have a huge impact on someone’s life. Darwin is a top performer, earning nearly 4 times the minimum wage simply by using a motorbike. On average across the cohort of 55 individuals, incomes doubled. This loan helped place these individuals on a different trajectory.

At an institutional level, the lack of transparency is a huge risk. One microfinance institution we spoke with had to replace their entire country team because of fraud. A loan on Celo provides more transparency to the entire financial chain — providing tighter financial controls. This was put to action during the pilot when we caught a fraud attempt thanks to the traceability through the financial chain.
As total value locked on DeFi has boomed in the crypto industry, the full potential of decentralized finance is far from realized. All major DeFi protocols require substantial overcollateralization. Meanwhile the people who benefit most from credit have the least access. Would you take a bet on Jorge if you knew the loan might double his income?

Informal financial solutions are built on the foundation that communities will help each other. It can work exceptionally well for small groups, but doing it analog prevents scale. Today, most of these relationships are limited to small communities, and the trust within a community is only useful in a different community with an explicit social bridge. In the best-case scenario today, the credit score in one country is useful only as far as the physical border of that country. This pilot highlights that there are ways to organically scale these relationships. We imagine a future where these credit scores are fully self-custodial and can be used much the same way as collateral in the physical world.
The pilot run in early 2020 has grown into Roda and today has reached over 200 individuals. The loans have covered everything from a new phone to the ability to take a maternity leave. The increased earnings from the loans today exceeds $400,000.
A microloan on Celo has the potential to reward trust, help communities prosper together, and connect those with capital to those without. For Jorge and his community we’ve already seen an immediate impact on their daily lives. How might we empower and scale even more communities with solutions like this on Celo?
DeFi
DeFi for the People
Blockchain for Good
Latest


