Date

Author

Celo Core Co.

Celo Core Co.

A Celo NFT-backed Rewards Pilot a Success In San Francisco

a-celo-nft-backed-rewards-pilot-a-success-in-san-francisco

Reading time

7 minutes

Share

Copy link

By Evan Fenster, Celo Foundation

Atlas Cafe coffeehouse in San Francisco’s Mission district has been a mainstay in the neighborhood since 1996, providing a comfortable place for the local community to eat, drink, socialize, and work. Unfortunately, the pandemic hit Atlas Cafe hard — its ‘regulars’ came a lot less often, as stay-at-home orders disrupted typical routines. This scenario occurred all across the country and around the world. While most businesses have reopened, some have struggled to rebuild their regular clientele. Atlas Cafe was no exception.

As an Atlas customer over the summer, a UPenn student working as a summer intern on the Celo Foundation’s Research and Innovation team, and someone who has seen how NFT projects can build brands and communities, I wanted to explore how NFTs might help a local business. This exploration led to an NFT-backed rewards pilot program that simulated how a neighborhood coffee shop could market, onboard, manage, and implement an NFT collection used for rewards.

To run the pilot, I received funding from the Celo Foundation and help from my Research and Innovation teammates. Ultimately a success, the pilot served as proof-of-concept for a decentralized rewards protocol called Loka, which is currently in development.

The Atlas Pilot Concept and Design

In May 2022, I began researching how NFT-backed rewards work to help businesses create loyal customers and possibly increase revenue and brand awareness. I discovered that an NFT collection could be a great tool for developing and managing customer loyalty. After all, long-term rewards programs for coffee subscriptions have been tried and tested, and many brands have already used NFTs to successfully tap into desired customer behavior. But, in my research, I couldn’t find any examples that combined these two strategies.

The use-case design is fairly simple: A business rewards customers with an NFT from a branded collection in an attempt to increase loyalty. The hope is that by giving away an NFT that entitles consumers to a small reward, businesses can entice them to visit more often and spend enough to make up for the cost of the reward, increasing overall profit.

The Atlas Cafe NFT collection was deployed to the Celo blockchain and featured the Atlas mascot, designed by Atlas Cafe and Celo Foundation. Each NFT is collectible, tradable, and transferable, and entitled the holders to redeem a free coffee, valued at $4.50, every day for the duration of the 10-day pilot.

The Pilot

On July 25, 2022, I launched the 10-day Atlas Cafe pilot with 20 participants I met at the cafe and asked to join. I sent each participant an NFT directly to the wallet addresses they designated prior. Throughout the pilot period, they could redeem their free Atlas coffee once a day by showing their NFT to baristas. Since the NFTs exist on the Celo blockchain, participants could also use existing tools to view, trade, sell, and transfer them. For example, they could sell the NFT reward from their mobile phones using TofuNFT.com.

The tofunft.com mobile ‘buy’ interface.


To help inform pilot results, participants were given a form with their coffee, and asked to list other purchases, if any, and the cost of those purchases. These purchases were made with fiat currencies.

Atlas Rewards Pilot Results

When the 10-day pilot ended, the data was collected and analyzed. Here are the results:

NFT-based rewards helped increase visits and overall revenue for Atlas Cafe. Pilot participants visited the cafe more frequently and purchased additional items when there. Before the NFT-based reward, one participant visited Atlas Cafe about once a month, spending an average of $5 per visit. After receiving the reward, he visited a total of five times over the 10-day pilot period, spending about $28 in total. Another participant, who noted similar pre-pilot spending, visited three times over the 10-day pilot period, spending a total of $24.

“I was a super-huge fan of the concept and idea of an NFT membership pass for supporting local businesses,” said pilot participant Doug Qian. “In the 10-day pilot, I stopped by Atlas almost every day to pick up a coffee, and it became a pretty critical part of my morning routine. Would gladly pay for a pass like this in the future.”

Atlas Cafe increased its brand awareness through on-chain earned marketing and word of mouth. Atlas Cafe’s brand awareness grew as pilot participants spread the word about their experiences. They were enamored with the ability to hold an on-chain, Atlas Cafe NFT in their wallet, and began telling others about the pilot. This word-of-mouth marketing resulted in seven additional people joining the pilot in the first few days.

The NFT collection created global reach for the local cafe. Four of the 27 total participants joined the pilot from Uganda, Africa. Though unable to receive the free coffee, they joined to engage with the Celo and Atlas Cafe communities. By creating this collection, Atlas Cafe was able to obtain a global reach with minimal marketing spend.

On-chain tools provided other use-case opportunities. One participant wanted to transfer the reward from his original wallet to another. Since the reward was represented as NFT, he was able to seamlessly do so. Another participant, who was out of town during the 10-day pilot period, listed his NFT for sale on an open marketplace, making a $7 profit. The new owner was then able to join the rewards pilot for a minimal cost.

A resale transaction between two participants.


“The pilot was of incredible help in understanding a customer segment we have wanted to understand,” says Felipe Collin, owner of Atlas Cafe. “After COVID, every business worldwide started looking for ways to engage and provide additional value to their customers. As the pilot started, we saw a social element growing in parallel — people coordinating to grab a coffee as a group. NFT loyalty programs are a great way to engage with your customers and build a community.”

Future Considerations

While Atlas Cafe benefited from the NFT-backed rewards program pilot, functionality must be added to create a fully developed protocol for business use:

  • Automate reward redemption and integrate data collection. Like any cafe, certain times of the day at Atlas are busier than others. For that and other reasons, Atlas Cafe staff often failed to ask customers to complete the form after each transaction. While this limited the amount of reliable data we collected at the register, we were able to supplement the self-reports with on-chain data, interviews, and surveys. To avoid interruptions in the check-out process in the future, automating reward redemption and data collection will help guarantee a smoother check-out experience, regardless of the type of business.

  • Expand this model to other businesses (e.g., larger restaurants, local grocery stores) to increase engagement in vertical markets. Statistica survey data released in June 2022 suggests that consumers, on average, participate in over 16 loyalty programs, yet are active in less than eight of them. Utilizing NFTs in a loyalty program can allow consumers to stay more engaged with the brand, as we saw with this pilot.

  • Develop additional on-chain NFT use cases. Use cases for NFT holders could include on-chain voting. For example, Atlas Cafe could present an on-chain proposal to introduce a new drink, which only their NFT holders could vote on. The on-chain voting process would provide utility for the NFT holders while also resulting in useful consumer data for Atlas. Additionally, brands could host networking and other events only for NFT holders.

Small businesses like Atlas Cafe can seamlessly generate NFT-backed rewards that can help improve customer retention rates while increasing profits. Once developed, the decentralized rewards protocol Loka could help even the smallest business integrate and innovate with web3 technologies.

To learn more about Celo and its mission to create a future where people everywhere can thrive from financial inclusion, a healthy environment, and connectivity through innovative technologies, visit Celo.org.

NFTs

Initiatives